Court of Appeal reverses Employment Court decision on discretionary incentive payments

Discretionary payments have been a relatively grey area for businesses, and employers have sought, by contract or by policy, to avoid their liability to include bonus payments in any annual leave payment calculations on these grounds.

In 2020 the Employment Court made a decision which found these short-term incentive payments made by Metropolitan Glass and Glazing Ltd that were conditional on meeting performance targets, should be included in holiday pay calculations and fell within the definition of ‘gross earnings’, even though the scheme was ‘discretionary’. However, this decision was recently overturned by the Court of Appeal.

The Court of Appeal stated that the Employment Court was erroneous as it overlooked the fact that the key element of the definition of “gross earnings” is that the payment must be one that the employer is contractually bound to pay. The definition of “discretionary payment” is a payment that the employer is not contractually bound to pay.

The definition of “gross earnings” under the Holidays Act includes “all payments that the employer is required to pay to the employee under the employee’s employment agreement”, but excludes “discretionary payments”. Metro Glass treated these incentive payments as “discretionary payments” and therefore, excluded the payments from holiday pay calculations.

The Employment Court found that found that any incentive scheme recorded in writing and including performance-based metrics is likely to be considered ‘non-discretionary”, whereas the Court of Appeal upheld Metro Glass’ appeal, finding that payments made under its incentive scheme were “discretionary payments” and could therefore be excluded from “gross earnings” calculations.

The CoA held that “Metropolitan … included an express term that even if all of the conditions were met, it retained the discretion not to make any payment”. They also found that the discretion would need to be exercised in good faith and a failure to do so could create grounds for personal grievance.

The Court of Appeal did agree with the Employment Court in the fact that the scheme sat in a separate document outside of the Employment Agreement was irrelevant and that the critical question was whether it was contractually binding on Metro Glass.

So, what does this mean for employers going forward?

Based on the Court of Appeal’s decision, provided employers expressly retain discretion to withhold incentive payments in any relevant incentive schemes (or similar), even if specified targets are achieved, such payments will not need to be included in “gross earnings”.

However, an incentive scheme simply reserving a discretion as to the amount to be paid or conditions to be met for payment, would not be considered discretionary. The key to discretion that employers would need to reserve is whether to make a payment at all, regardless of whether conditions for the payment have been met or not.

Something to be aware of is that this result might not hold up for much longer with the Holidays Act taskforce recommending that all cash payments made to employees be factored into holiday pay entitlements, except for direct reimbursements.

Disclaimer

This article, and any information contained on our website is necessarily brief and general in nature, and should not be substituted for professional advice. You should always seek professional advice before taking any action in relation to the matters addressed.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Christmas is coming…

Christmas is coming…

Once Labour Day has been [yes, believe it or not it’s this coming Monday], the next public holidays are at Christmas and New Year. It always feels like employers have to put a bit more thought into Christmas and New Year because: there are four public holidays; this is a time that many businesses have their annual closedown period; many employees take their annual leave; some employees don’t have enough leave to cover this period; some employment agreements have special rates for these public holidays; and, let’s face it, it is a busy busy busy time. In the next few weeks, my colleague, Tasneem Begum, and I will be offering a free webinar for those employers who want a bit more information around those tricky calculations for leave at this time of the year. We will also be able to answer the questions you have and the challenges you face with leave during the Christmas/New Year period. You are not alone with the questions you have – Questions we are often asked at this time of the year are about employing staff to cover the busy Christmas period

Read More
One of those weeks: Mental Health Awareness Week 2022

One of those weeks: Mental Health Awareness Week 2022

I have had one of those weeks where I have been in full day mediations virtually every day out of Auckland. What hit me at these mediations is the despair that people find themselves in by the time they arrive at my door. With varying degrees, all of these mediations had people in deep emotional turmoil. Anguish, frustration, anger and deep sadness, to the point where I had to pause to ensure the people were in the right space to make good decisions for themselves.

Read More
What the heck is going on with pay?

What the heck is going on with pay?

While we are conscious of the impact that inflation is having on wage and salary conversations, there are four other levers that have been, and are being, used to bring about fundamental change and significant uplift to pay in New Zealand. The Government is using these levers to drive increases in pay at various levels in ways that we may not be conscious of. However, when brought together as a single thread, they are having a big impact.

Read More
PREV NEXT