Without Prejudice Off Record Discussions Risky

Posted on: Apr 19, 2013

BlakelyACM New Zealand Ltd [2013] NZERA Christchurch 9 provides a textbook example of how not to initiate a “without prejudice” discussion about termination of employment.

In that case, an employer was dissatisfied with the performance of one of its managers and resolved to dismiss her. The employer did not advise the employee about its dissatisfaction with her work. Instead, it required the employee to attend a meeting. The employer worked from a prepared script. The employer said that a dispute had arisen about the employee’s attitude to the workplace and her behaviour and that it considered continuation of the employee’s employment to be untenable. It then said it wished to conduct a discussion on a without prejudice basis and make an offer to resolve the dispute. The employee did not accept the offer and a few days later the employee resigned. The employee raised a personal grievance and alleged constructive dismissal. The employer denied the claim and submitted the Employment Relations Authority was not entitled to take the “without prejudice” discussion into consideration.

The Authority held that the employee had clearly been constructively dismissed and the employer’s conduct was intended to procure her resignation. The Authority also held that it was entitled to take the “without prejudice” discussion into account because:

(i)  the employer made it clear to the employee she would be dismissed before it asked to conduct the      interview on a without prejudice basis
(ii)  there was no dispute at the relevant time, and
(iii) normally an employer should carry out a proper disciplinary process.

This case highlights the importance of not entering into without prejudice or off the record discussions unless an employment dispute or personal grievance has first been raised.  Without a current dispute in progress, you are not protected by the privileged statements (section 121) provision of the Employment Relations Act 2000.

Disclaimer

This article, and any information contained on our website is necessarily brief and general in nature, and should not be substituted for professional advice. You should always seek professional advice before taking any action in relation to the matters addressed.

Disclaimer

This article, and any information contained on our website is necessarily brief and general in nature, and should not be substituted for professional advice. You should always seek professional advice before taking any action in relation to the matters addressed.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Changes

Changes

After recently assisting clients from different industries with different types of changes to their businesses, in both adding and removing roles or simply changing duties for some employees, I reflected on my own work history and the changes I had experienced over the last 40 years, including reference points at different stages of my life and how they impacted decisions I made or how I viewed change…

Read More
Modern Slavery Consultation Paper released

Modern Slavery Consultation Paper released

MBIE has recently released a consultation paper on Modern Slavery and are seeking feedback on a proposed legislative response to modern slavery and worker exploitation, forced labour, and people trafficking. The aim of the legislation is “to achieve freedom, fairness and dignity… and to address modern slavery and worker exploitation, both in New Zealand and internationally.” Submissions for consultation are open until 07 June 2022. Make sure you have your say.

Read More
The Great Merger

The Great Merger

Eight months ago, I joined Three60 Consult just as Auckland went into Lockdown. Like a lot of us, I thought it would be a short, sharp COVID battle and I remember optimistically suggesting to my boss that we push my start date out for a week.  Thank goodness she rejected my offer! Starting a new job in lockdown had its challenges, but returning to the office after an extended period, as many of us have found, presented just as many. It was a full six months after my start date before I finally sat at my desk. Even then, the emergence of Omicron meant the whole team was not able to come together. Rather, we worked in mini team bubbles. Today as I write, eight months have passed since my start date and I’m finally seeing the full team come together on a more regular basis.

Read More
PREV NEXT